Path: utzoo!utgpu!jarvis.csri.toronto.edu!rutgers!apple!agate!shelby!lindy!philf
From: philf@lindy.Stanford.EDU (Phil Fernandez)
Newsgroups: comp.sys.mac.programmer
Subject: I need User Interface Advice on Toolbox Palette Window
Message-ID: <3798@lindy.Stanford.EDU>
Date: 11 Jul 89 15:34:07 GMT
Sender: philf@lindy.Stanford.EDU (Phil Fernandez)
Reply-To: philf@lindy.UUCP (Phil Fernandez)
Organization: Metaphor Computer Systems
Lines: 27


I am implementing a fairly specialized text-and-graphics manipulation
program, and will have a toolbox palette GhostWindow with draw tools,
text tool, etc.

When the program starts, the palette will open automatically and be
located near the drawing area; however, I'm looking for advice about
how the user should reopen the window if closed.

I've seen at least 2 models:

--A tear-off menu under a "Tools" menu heading.  This is the HyperCard and
MacPaint model.

--A toggle menu item under a "Windows" menu.  I.e., the first item
under the "Windows" menu is an on/off toggle for the palette window.
This is the Freehand model.

I was looking for advice about which of these approaches is "better"
-- i.e., more standard or familiar, or advice or suggestions about
other approaches.  All thoughts welcome.

Please reply directly to me:

Internet:  philf@lindy.stanford.edu  
UUCP:      {...}!sun!lindy.stanford.edu!philf

phil