Path: utzoo!utgpu!news-server.csri.toronto.edu!cs.utexas.edu!wuarchive!udel!princeton!phoenix!dmlaur
From: dmlaur@phoenix.Princeton.EDU (David M. Laur)
Newsgroups: comp.sys.sgi
Subject: Re: (lack of symbol tables in) sgi distributions
Message-ID: <2590@idunno.Princeton.EDU>
Date: 18 Sep 90 17:57:35 GMT
References: <1990Sep17.075217.18381@utstat.uucp> <1990Sep17.201711.20000@relay.wpd.sgi.com>
Sender: news@idunno.Princeton.EDU
Organization: ICGL, Princeton University, Princeton, New Jersey
Lines: 40

Bean Anderson, SGI (WPD), writes:
>2.  Tape space is, perhaps, even more important.  Unstripped binaries
>would double the number of tapes required for a release.   At our
>current size, that would add approximately $300,000 of cost per extra
>tape to our distribution cost.  Our cost for the next release then
>will be approximately $1,000,000 extra just to have unstripped binaries.
>
>Those are two key reasons for stipping binaries.  New distribution 
>media (such as CD-ROM) will/may solve the second issue and maybe 
>even the first as we could ship both stripped and unstripped binaries.

-------

Would user savings in maintenance costs pay for the CD-ROM reader?
Would SGI save enough to just send one along?
Do options such as Fortran or NFS add as much per tape per distribution?

-------

>Lastly, I totaly agree that some minimal symbol table information
>should be available.  We are looking at that issue now. 
>
>			Bean

Would symbol tables for the GL,etc really be useful? Our experience
has been that programs which crash "inside" a system routine usually
are calling the system routine with bad args, which lint or the new
"-prototypes" option to cc will find; or they've walked off the end
of an array somewhere, rendering the symbol table useless anyway.
For sites that really need the symbol table, maybe a seperate option
should be sold, allowing them to alternately link with a special
version of the libraries (-lgl_Sym ?).

- David

David Laur
Interactive Computer Graphics Lab
Princeton University
dmlaur@manray.princeton.edu
609-258-4609