Path: utzoo!utgpu!news-server.csri.toronto.edu!cs.utexas.edu!uunet!saxony!pesch
From: pesch@pa.reuter.COM (Roland Pesch)
Newsgroups: comp.sys.atari.st.tech
Subject: Re: TOS 1.4 vs old (1988) ICD HD utils [solved]
Summary: Thanks to all who helped, and details of what works and what doesn't.
Keywords: TOS 1.4, ICD, icdboot, bombs
Message-ID: <413@saxony.pa.reuter.COM>
Date: 25 Sep 90 00:18:34 GMT
Organization: Reuter:file Inc  (A Reuter Company) Palo Alto, CA
Lines: 43

[I *think* this didn't make it out the first time; apologies if I'm
wrong, and cluttering up the net.]

My thanks to all who responded wrt my problem (TOS 1.4/old ICD utils
incompatibility), most notably "Hardware Dave"
hardware@rose.waterloo.edu, who actually had previous experience of
the problem; Shoou-yu Tang (sytang@skyblue.ACNS.ColoState.Edu), who
thought he did too; and also to those others who simply offered
sympathy and encouragement...  I'm now happily reading from my hard
disk again.

The problem was indeed, as seemed likely, the old icdboot program.

For "the record", here are the specifics ---in case they are of use to
someone planning an upgrade to TOS 1.4:

   --> icdboot.prg version 2.1 CRASHES RELIABLY (even when it is the
*only* startup) under TOS 1.4.  (I went and crashed off floppy one
last time to get that version number, after everything was fixed.  Two
bombs, if anyone counts)

   --> the latest version from ICD's bulletin board (815) 968-2229, as
of a few weeks ago, works fine.  In particular, I am now successfully
using version 4.8.4 with TOS 1.4.

   --> it is NOT necessary to reinitialize the hard disk to switch.

In case it matters, the computer is a 1040 STFM with the following
arcane markings on its motherboard:
       C07053-001 REV. C
       GX-211 V0 1986



                       /Roland

Roland Pesch			pesch@pa.reuter.com		(415) 327-1700
      :Reuters::425 Sherman Av., Ste 200::Palo Alto CA::94306:

-- 

Roland Pesch			pesch@pa.reuter.com		(415) 327-1700
          :Reuters::425 Sherman Av., Ste 200::Palo Alto CA::94306: