Xref: utzoo news.groups:26107 comp.sys.att:11042 unix-pc.general:6694
Path: utzoo!utgpu!watserv1!watmath!att!tut.cis.ohio-state.edu!galaxia!dave
From: dave@galaxia.Newport.RI.US (David H. Brierley)
Newsgroups: news.groups,comp.sys.att,unix-pc.general
Subject: Re: Reorganization of comp.sys.att (was: CFD: create comp.sys.3
Message-ID: <1092@galaxia.Newport.RI.US>
Date: 3 Dec 90 14:26:57 GMT
References: <8352@gollum.twg.com> <36346@cup.portal.com> <947@trac2000.ueci.com>
Organization: Dave's Very Own Personal System
Lines: 35

I won't bore you with thousands of lines of included articles, just my 2 cents
worth.

I am strongly in favor of creating a new main-stream group to *replace* the
existing unix-pc.* hierarchy.  My primary reason for this is to solve the
problem of poor connectivity.  There are several major sites that refuse to
carry the unix-pc groups because they are not part of the main-stream and
as a result there are many isolated pockets of activity.  Since the unix-pc
(aka pc-7300, aka 3b1) has been officially abandoned by ATT, the newsgroup
is the primary means of support available to most of the owners of the machine.
Improved connectivity for a group designated for discussion of this machine
would greatly benefit all of the people who own one.

I think the issue of reorganizing comp.sys.att into multiple sub-groups is
a separate but not completely un-related issue.  Some people seem to strongly
support a reorg so I am therefore changing my original position and am now
coming out in favor of the name 'comp.sys.att.3b1'.  I am also in favor of
a moderated sources group called 'comp.sources.3b1'.  When I orginally
proposed a moderated sources group I volunteered to act as moderator and I
am still willing.  I am also seeking volunteers to act as co-moderators so
that we can avoid problems in the future.  I envision my role as moderator
as simply a filter to ensure that all of the postings are either source
programs or patches.

In summary, I think we should proceed with creating comp.sys.att.3b1 and
comp.sources.3b1 (moderated).  The issue of attempting a reorganization of
the other ATT machines into subgroups can be dealt with later but by naming
this group as a subgroup of c.s.a we have paved the way for the reorg (or
at least we have not done anything to block it).

Let's Vote!
-- 
David H. Brierley
Home: dave@galaxia.Newport.RI.US    Work: dhb@quahog.ssd.ray.com
Can I be excused, my brain is full.