Path: utzoo!utgpu!news-server.csri.toronto.edu!rutgers!sun-barr!lll-winken!catnip!bandy
From: bandy@catnip.berkeley.ca.us (Gun Control is Hitting Your Target)
Newsgroups: comp.os.cpm
Subject: Re: System use of Z80 registers
Message-ID: <663@catnip.berkeley.ca.us>
Date: 9 Dec 90 17:22:48 GMT
References: <9011261759.AA10916@newton> <6209@balu.UUCP>
Organization: The People's Number Four Cat Farm, Berkeley CA, USA
Lines: 43

I agree with Bridger, disagree with Tilmann and give my take on the
situation, plus official word from DRI.  

Bridger Mitchell writes:
>> I (and others) have long argued strenuously for strict adherence to
>> the following systems-programming guideline:
>>
>>				 ****
>>   SYSTEM CODE (BIOS, BDOS, INTERRUPT-SERVICE ROUTINES, AND BACKGROUND
>>   UTILITIES)  SHOULD *ALWAYS PRESERVE* THE NON-8080 REGISTERS.
>>				 ****
>>
>> This rule ensures that an application that uses Z80 opcodes can run on
>> any z80 system without having to save and restore any of those
>> registers before every BIOS and BDOS call.

tilmann@cosmo.UUCP (Tilmann Reh) writes:
>That's a guideline I don't agree with.
>Why should the system care about which registers the application program uses?

Why?  "Because CP/M is an **8080** operating system - thus it may only use
8080 registers."  I got this reply back from Digital Research back in '80
when I asked them about the Z/80 registers.

>Of course, interrupt routines must also save all registers they use, as this
>are asynchronous events.

That's right, but the silly people who did the Osborne-1 roms didn't. 
Hence perfectly valid Z80 applications that ran on other folks' systems
would crash on the Osborne. 

>When will programmers (system *and* application) finally understand that
>everything should be programmed as portable and universal as possible ?

Exactly.

Yes, it would make an application even more bullet proof to have it save
all the Z80 registers [or don't use them :-)] before it called into
BDOS/BIOS, but folks who write BIOS software should preserve the Z80
registers to help maintain compatibility with "incorrect" software.
-- 
real address: bandy@catnip.berkeley.ca.us
last choice:  lll-winken!catnip.berkeley.ca.us!bandy