Path: utzoo!utgpu!news-server.csri.toronto.edu!rpi!uwm.edu!bionet!hayes.ims.alaska.edu!gateway!dont-send-mail-to-path-lines From: dwelch@tzone.UUCP (Dan Welch) Newsgroups: rec.music.gaffa Subject: heresy, smeresy, _Hounds_ rules Message-ID: <9103182156.AA03207@tzone.mpd.tandem.com> Date: 18 Mar 91 21:56:05 GMT Sender: Love-Hounds-request@ims.alaska.edu Organization: The Internet Lines: 26 Approved: Love-Hounds@hayes.ims.alaska.edu In article AGOUGH%FAB6@SC.INTEL.COM writes: > >This heresy has to end right now. "The Dreaming" is the best album (as |>oug >will attest). In fact, "The Dreaming" is the ** ONLY ** album that exists. >Its existence denies the reality of all others. > >-andy Sorry, Andy, have to disagree here . . . HoL is the best. Kate's voice is better, and the scope of her vision is breath-taking, to say the least. TD is virtually without flaw, but the one it does suffer from is that the whole is only slightly more than the sum of the parts. HoL, on the other hand, may be viewed (as an album) on so many different levels (a collection of songs, a story, an allegory, dream-sequence, etc.) that as a work of art it cannot be approached. Does anybody else suffer from the syndrome that, once HoL is played, you have to shut off the stereo? Because, after all, what would you play next? ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | Daniel Welch | "Kate Bush is the sort of performer | | Tandem Computers, Inc. | for whom the word 'superstar' is | | Austin, TX, USA | belittling." | | halley!tzone!dwelch@cs.utexas.edu | Mike Davies, _Melody_Maker_ | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------