Xref: utzoo comp.lang.c:39292 comp.std.c:4835
Path: utzoo!utgpu!news-server.csri.toronto.edu!cs.utexas.edu!swrinde!zaphod.mps.ohio-state.edu!think.com!mintaka!mit-eddie!apollo!vinoski
From: vinoski@apollo.HP.COM (Stephen Vinoski)
Newsgroups: comp.lang.c,comp.std.c
Subject: Re: Question on ANSI ## pre-processor operator.
Message-ID: <519416cd.20b6d@apollo.HP.COM>
Date: 15 May 91 14:46:00 GMT
References: <28302040.69ED@deneva.sdd.trw.com>
Sender: root@apollo.HP.COM
Reply-To: vinoski@apollo.HP.COM (Stephen Vinoski)
Followup-To: comp.lang.c
Organization: Hewlett-Packard Apollo Division - Chelmsford, MA
Lines: 45

In article <28302040.69ED@deneva.sdd.trw.com> knurlin@spf.trw.com (Scott Karlin) writes:
>I am looking for a clarification on the ANSI-C token merging
>operator (##).  According to H&S:  "After *all* [emphasis mine]
>macro replacements have been done, the two tokens surrounding
>any ## operator are combined into a single token."  I interpret
>this to mean that:
>
>#define INDEX 0
>#define FN_NAME(x) name ## x
>void FN_NAME(INDEX) () { printf("Hello\n"); }

(I have cross-posted this to comp.std.c since a similar question
recently came up there.  Follow-ups have been directed to
comp.lang.c.)

I had a problem with token pasting similar to yours.  A compiler
writer said that the problem was caused by the fact that I was
attempting to paste arbitrary text with macro parameters; he said that
token pasting is only meant to work on macro parameters.

The ANSI C standard appears to agree with him; I believe it is section
3.8.3.3 (I don't have the standard handy) that says that ## causes
macro parameters to be pasted together.  If I have misinterpreted the
standard, I'm sure I will hear about it.  :-)

I have also noticed that K&R II only shows macro parameters being
pasted together.

What if you change your example to:

#define INDEX 0
#define REAL_FN_NAME(x,y) x ## y
#define FN_NAME(x)        REAL_FN_NAME(name,x)

Then your example usage:

>void FN_NAME(INDEX) () { printf("Hello\n"); }

should produce the desired result.


-steve

| Steve Vinoski  (508)256-0176 x5904       | Internet: vinoski@apollo.hp.com  |
| HP Apollo Division, Chelmsford, MA 01824 | UUCP: ...!apollo!vinoski         |