Path: utzoo!utgpu!news-server.csri.toronto.edu!rpi!usc!wuarchive!uunet!convex!usenet
From: tchrist@convex.COM (Tom Christiansen)
Newsgroups: comp.unix.shell
Subject: Re: cat, pipes, and filters
Keywords: cat pipe filter
Message-ID: <1991May31.195653.24211@convex.com>
Date: 31 May 91 19:56:53 GMT
References: <1991May31.165446.1530@progress.com>
Sender: usenet@convex.com (news access account)
Reply-To: tchrist@convex.COM (Tom Christiansen)
Organization: CONVEX Software Development, Richardson, TX
Lines: 45
Nntp-Posting-Host: pixel.convex.com

From the keyboard of root@progress.COM (Root of all Evil):
:
:Hi,
:
:   I've got a question regarding the way cat behaves in a pipeline.
:(I know, his fur gets all oily %+})  Can I cat the contents of a
:file | pipe the output to a filter (such as sed) | then cat the
:filtered output back to the original file?  I've tried this with the
:following commands:
:
:   cat $FILE | sed s/"$ENTRY"/"$NEWENTRY"/ > $FILE
:
:   cat $FILE | sed s/"$ENTRY"/"$NEWENTRY"/ | cat > $FILE
:
:Both command produce identical results: $FILE is truncated to 0-length.
:
:   However, the following command gives me the result I want:
:
:   cat $FILE | sed s/"$ENTRY"/"$NEWENTRY"/ | tee $FILE 1>/dev/null
:
:So now my script works but I don't really understand why.  I've tested
:this on SunOs 4.1 and Interactive SysV 2.2, no difference.  Is there
:something simple about pipes or I/O redirection that I'm not grasping?

yes.

:Or is this a feature of cat?  
:
:   Any enlightenment would be appreciated.  Also, if you can think of
:a better way to do the same thing (short of using perl), please let
:me know.

hm.... with that kind of proviso, i shouldn't answer.  :-)/2

you need to think about when things are getting opened.  the
shell opens your files before i calls the command.

so either use a temporary, cheat with tee, or else use

    perl -p -i -e "s/$ENTRY/$NEWENTRY/" $FILE

--tom
--
Tom Christiansen		tchrist@convex.com	convex!tchrist
		"So much mail, so little time."