Path: utzoo!yunexus!geac!syntron!jtsv16!uunet!munnari!bruce!goanna!yabbie!rcodi
From: rcodi@yabbie.rmit.oz (Ian Donaldson)
Newsgroups: comp.protocols.appletalk
Subject: Re: HELP NEEDED with KIP ROUTING
Message-ID: <885@yabbie.rmit.oz>
Date: 10 Oct 88 00:10:47 GMT
Article-I.D.: yabbie.885
References: <453@gould.doc.ic.ac.uk>
Organization: RMIT Comm & Elec Eng, Melbourne, Australia.
Lines: 64

From article <453@gould.doc.ic.ac.uk>, by voh@doc.ic.ac.uk (Vincent O Ho):

- mentions problem with KIP routing.

We have almost exactly the same problem with telnet on our Mac's.

Here is our current network topology:

	    Vaxen   Suns    HP9000's
	      |      |         |
	      |      |         |                       Comp-Sci cable 128.100 
	-----------------------------------------------------------
				      |
				      |
				128.100.11.42 (1st ethernet board)
			      [ENCORE Multimax]
				192.9.200.42  (2nd ethernet board)
				      |
				      |                Comm-Eng cable 192.9.200
	-----------------------------------------------------------
	     |     |                        |
	     |     |                        |
	    Suns  PC's            [ Kinetics-Fastpath-3 ]
					    |
					    |
					    |          Appletalk cable
	-----------------------------------------------------------
	     |
	     |
	   Macs

The Mac's in the above diagram can talk to any Sun on the Comm-Eng cable
using telnet/ftp/aufs with no problems at all.  They cannot however
talk to the Encore or anything on the Comp-Sci cable at all.  
The Comm-Eng Suns have no problems talking to the Encore but they each needed 
a "route add" to talk properly initially.  Likewise on the Comp-Sci cable,
their Vaxen and Suns can talk to us ok but a "route add" was needed.

Two Sun's are AUFS servers, with one of them being the Kip master for
the KFPS:

The atalkatab entry for the Kip master Sun (which is on the Comm-Eng
cable having 192.9.200.1 as its IP address):

----
55.200	N1	192.9.200.0	commeng		#herman, appletalk-in-IP
56.1	KC	appletalk	commeng		#herman, localtalk
	I192.9.200.0	I192.9.200.1		#ipbroad ipname
	I192.9.200.1	L0			#ipdebug ipfile
	L0 L0 L0 L0	S0 S0			#ipother atnetet unused
	LX0		S100	S15		#flags ipstatic ipdynamic
	S56.1	S55.200				#atneta atnete
----

Versions:  telnet 2.2
	   KIP 1/88
	   CAP 5.0
	   SunOS 3.5
	   Vax 4.3bsd (with early '88 tcp/ip from comp.bugs.4bsd.ucb-fixes)
	   Encore UMAX V (unixV31 ax.2.1.b 29JUL88 -- from uname -a)

Any help appreciated.

Ian D