Path: utzoo!utgpu!watmath!clyde!att!osu-cis!tut.cis.ohio-state.edu!bloom-beacon!athena.mit.edu!scs
From: scs@athena.mit.edu (Steve Summit)
Newsgroups: comp.unix.wizards
Subject: Unix security suggestion
Message-ID: <8064@bloom-beacon.MIT.EDU>
Date: 19 Nov 88 21:01:32 GMT
Sender: daemon@bloom-beacon.MIT.EDU
Reply-To: scs@adam.pika.mit.edu (Steve Summit)
Lines: 52

One of the disturbing things about Unix security is that bugs in
the protection mechanisms tend to be catastrophic: they don't
just let you do some little unintended thing; more often than not
they let you do anything, as root.  For instance, Guy Harris
recently reminded us of

	rlogin host -l ''

which (I assume) makes use of the

	::0:0:::

lines which are, incredibly, still routinely left in the passwd
file by broken software.  I find it rather astonishing that these
"turds" in the passwd file not only do not prevent the file's
being read (most bugs break things badly), but in fact happen to
introduce everybody's worst nightmare: a wide open, unrestricted
security hole.

Of course, in Computer Science, as in Mathematics, as in Nature,
everything drains towards 0, so the fact that uid 0 is both the
superuser and the most likely accidental value can be seen as an
invitation to disaster.

If only the kernel tested for superuser status neither with

	if(!u.u_uid)

nor with

	if(u.uid == 0)

but with

	if(u.uid == SUPERUSER)

Then it would be a relatively simple matter to re#define
SUPERUSER to some really unlikely value.  (I have seen kernel
code which uses if(suser()), which would also allow easy
remapping.)

I am quite aware of how well-entrenched is the notion that the
superuser is uid 0, and what a massive and error-prone
undertaking such a redefinition would consequently be.

This is a good example of why embedding "magic numbers" and other
assumptions in source code (rather than using #defines or other
modular practices) is almost never a good idea.  (Ah, the acuity
of 20/20 hindsight.)

                                            Steve Summit
                                            scs@adam.pika.mit.edu