Path: utzoo!utgpu!jarvis.csri.toronto.edu!mailrus!csd4.milw.wisc.edu!lll-winken!uunet!fed!arccs1!m1rcd00
From: m1rcd00@arccs1.FRB.GOV (Bob Drzyzgula)
Newsgroups: comp.lang.lisp
Subject: Re: Trouble Compiling KCL on Sun3/SunOS4
Summary: Making Progress...
Keywords: KCL, Sun, SunOS4.0
Message-ID: <478@arcfs1.fed.FRB.GOV>
Date: 4 Apr 89 19:40:35 GMT
References: <476@arcfs1.fed.FRB.GOV>
Sender: news@fed.FRB.GOV
Reply-To: rcd@fed.frb.gov (Bob Drzyzgula)
Organization: Federal Reserve Board, Washington, DC
Lines: 117

Thank you all very much for your responses. There were four basic
suggestions:

	1. Use the gcc compiler. (Moises Lejter)
	2. Use -Bstatic on the Sun C compiler. (Mark Lerner)
	   (to Mark: You suggest that there is a step in the beginning
	   where the makefiles get rewritten. I have looked again
	   through all of the distribution, and I cannot find
	   any such configuration process. I got my copy from uunet.
	   Am I missing something?)
	3. Patch the source (Taizo Kojima's patches are included here).
	4. Buy IBCL. (a solicitation from the purveyor)

So, I first tried using the gcc comiler. To do this, I wound up having
to make two changes: I put -w in the gcc commands, since it got *real*
upset about one of the header files (external.h) not meeting gnu's
specs. I also had to patch the dpp preprocessor to make it generate
gnu-standard #line directives. (gnu uses # linenum filename, and the
filename has to be in double quotes in the general case. Sun's cc uses
#line linenum filename, and doesn't need the quotes. This is real easy
to find... search for #line in dpp.c). This got past loading cmpmain.lsp,
but choked on another memory error soon after loading setdoc.lsp
(transcript later).

Second, I tried putting -Bstatic on Sun's cc (yes, including the
one at the bottom of unixport/makefile that doesn't use CFLAGS). This
made no discernable difference in the outcome.

This was when Taizo Kojima's mail came in. I applied that patch, and
the Sun cc version ran through the cmpmain.lsp, but *failed in exactly
the same place as gcc*. So although I have achieved syncronization
between the two compilers, I have not gotten a running kcl. You've done
great so far, any more ideas? (Yes, I have run memory diagnostics on
my Sun and even tried a seperate compile on a different machine
[a 3/180])

Again, thanks. Transcript of failure follows, followed by Taizo
Kojima's patches:

	Initializing cmpvar...  
	Initializing cmpvs...  
	Initializing cmpwt...  
	Loading ../cmpnew/cmpmain.lsp
	Finished loading ../cmpnew/cmpmain.lsp
	Loading ../cmpnew/lfun_list.lsp
	Finished loading ../cmpnew/lfun_list.lsp
	Loading ../cmpnew/cmpopt.lsp
	Finished loading ../cmpnew/cmpopt.lsp
	Warning: COMPILE-FILE is being redefined.
	Warning: COMPILE is being redefined.
	Warning: DISASSEMBLE is being redefined.
	Loading ../lsp/setdoc.lsp
	Finished loading ../lsp/setdoc.lsp
	Warning: LISP-IMPLEMENTATION-VERSION is being redefined.sh: 954 Memory
	fault - core dumped
	*** Error code 139
	make: Fatal error: Command failed for target `saved_kcl'
	Current working directory /src/kcl/unixport
	*** Error code 1
	make: Fatal error: Command failed for target `all'



>Hello Mr.Drzyzgula
>
> The reason of a memory fault is the implicit return value of
>new Sun C compiler.
> To avoid this, you must add 2 lines at bottom of the functions
>using asm() statement, get_mark_bit() and get_set_mark_bit() in
>c/bitop.c:
>
>======= in bitop.c
>get_mark_bit(x)
>int *x;
>{
>	asm("	movl	a6@(8),d0");
>	asm("	lsrl	#2,d0");
>	asm("	movl	d0,d1");
>	asm("	lsrl	#3,d1");
>	asm("	movl	_mark_table,a0");
>	asm("	btst	d0,a0@(0,d1:L)");
>	asm("	sne	d0");
>	asm("	andl	#1,d0");
>
>	asm("   unlk    a6");	/* for SunOS4.0 */
>	asm("   rts");		/* for SunOS4.0 */
>
>}
>
>get_set_mark_bit(x)
>int *x;
>{
>	asm("	movl	a6@(8),d0");
>	asm("	lsrl	#2,d0");
>	asm("	movl	d0,d1");
>	asm("	lsrl	#3,d1");
>	asm("	movl	_mark_table,a0");
>	asm("	bset	d0,a0@(0,d1:L)");
>	asm("	sne	d0");
>	asm("	andl	#1,d0");
>
>	asm("   unlk    a6");	/* for SunOS4.0 */
>	asm("   rts");		/* for SunOS4.0 */
>}
>
>
>Next, CFLAGS in unixport/makefile, add '-Bstatic' option for static binding,
>and add '-Bstatic' option where '/bin/ld' is called in file c/unixfasl.c
>
>- - Bye.
>PS:
> Sorry of my poor English X-<.
>				Mitsubishi Electric, Amagasaki, Japan
>				Taizo Kojima
Bob Drzyzgula
rcd@fed.frb.gov, uunet!fed!rcd
Federal Reserve Board, Washington, DC  20551