Path: utzoo!utgpu!jarvis.csri.toronto.edu!rutgers!usc!samsung!uakari.primate.wisc.edu!uwm.edu!bionet!ames!zodiac!jtn From: jtn@zodiac.ADS.COM (John Nelson) Newsgroups: comp.sys.mac Subject: TEXT File madness Message-ID: <10308@zodiac.ADS.COM> Date: 6 Jan 90 22:46:32 GMT Organization: Advanced Decision Systems, Mountain View, CA 94043, (415) 960-7300 Lines: 50 In article <8315@cbnewsm.ATT.COM> mls@cbnewsm.ATT.COM (mike.siemon) writes: > >The defensiveness of Mac fanatics about the oddities of the system is >obscuring the point. It is particularly obnoxious to be told that all Yes... I'm tired of the responses people are posting like "well just find your favorite editor and get into it and select the file you want to open and open it etc" when clearly the issue here is that the user DOES NOT want to go searching for an appropriate application. Rather he wants to simply double-click on the file and open it. Period. >The example of reading an arbitrary file is just that, an example of a >much larger general problem. If I have a file I may want to use it in >a number of different ways, totally unconstrained by the file's origin >or by my intentions when I create the file. I agree that this is a problem but a problem that can also be programmed around. I see no reaon why a DA could not be written to display a list of applications in a pull-down menu that one can immediately select and open your signature-less, creator-less file with. I also see no reason why the APple Finder could not be modified to take such unidentified files and apply a user-selecteable application to them... particularly if they have the type specified as "TEXT." Or how about a ResEdit DA that allows you to quickly and simply change the signature and creator types in arbitrary files? POWERFUL! The problem is that the file you speak of arrived onyour machine and was not created by any method particularly native to your machine ... i.e. it's just a text file that arrived through some means. It would be REALLY nice if the program you used had a menu entry that allowed you to specify the target creator and signature when the file is created on your system. That way the appropriate application can be run (most notably BinHex or Stuffit). Better yet the application you used should give the file a TeachText creator if none other is specified since TeachText is available on the system installation disks. There's ways around it that clever programmers can devise and still maintain the consistancey of the Mac and broaden it's generality. -- John T. Nelson UUCP: sun!sundc!potomac!jtn Advanced Decision Systems Internet: jtn@potomac.ads.com 1500 Wilson Blvd #512; Arlington, VA 22209-2401 (703) 243-1611